The AI compass

Summary

The Nantes Métropole doctrine states that AI can only be used within a predefined framework, evaluated through a "compass" that assesses:

• real contributions to public services and working conditions for city employees

• environmental sustainability

• transparency requirements

The "AI compass" proposes seven criteria against which any AI-based digital project will be evaluated.

The editorial perspective

The AI compass is an initiative designed to foster critical thinking before launching an AI-based project. It particularly emphasizes the social impact of AI-driven services. The seven criteria of the AI compass help evaluate the necessity and relevance of an AI solution.

The framework even suggests comparing the AI-powered solution to a non-AI alternative before making a decision. The overall approach appears coherent and provides essential safeguards to regulate AI projects.

However, more detailed explanations for each criterion would be useful to ensure a consistent understanding among all stakeholders and avoid subjective interpretations.

Additionally, in its current state, an AI project could technically meet the AI compass criteria while still being used for purposes that contradict ecological transition efforts (e.g., optimizing urban parking or traffic management, which could result in increased traffic volumes).